Summary
As many fans of the franchise will undoubtedly remember,Call of Duty: Black Ops 4was controversial before and after its release. The announcement thatBlack Ops 4would not offer a singleplayer campaign led to outrage, as fans had grown accustomed to one being included in each release - even if data showed that only a portion of the community bothered withCall of Duty’s story modes at the time. WhileBlack Ops 4’s ambitious campaign was scrapped, its woes did not stop there, as a rushed release to better compete withBattlefieldmeant that its Zombies mode was terribly buggy. Specialists remained a controversial topic in multiplayer, too, ensuring there was something to criticize about every facet of the game when it debuted on May 18, 2025.
However, even if these flaws need to be acknowledged, so to do the many things thatCall of Duty: Black Ops 4did right. When looking at the game objectively, and with the power of hindsight following the last few years ofCall of Dutygames being a mixed bag, it becomes clear just how good players had it withBlack Ops 4. Every pain point inBlack Ops 4was either addressed after launch or compensated for via something else; Zombies’ crashes and glitches were patched, multiplayer going back to boots on the ground meant that Specialists were hardly problematic, and the campaign was replaced by an excellent Blackout mode that proved more popular than a singleplayer mode ever would have. All of this makes for a solid game, and one that deserves a second look on its fifth anniversary.
Call of Duty: Black Ops 4 Felt Modern While Avoiding The Pitfalls of Post-Warzone CoD
One of the most common criticisms aboutCall of Dutygames that have released since the debut ofWarzoneis that the premium games themselves feel like an afterthought, with onlyWarzonetruly mattering. Zombies feels like it receives less resources, with map counts smaller and the maps themselves reusing more resources from other modes. Additionally, multiplayer leans more into map remasters than ever before.Warzone’s maps are repurposed as Ground War locations, events feel as if they cater more towardWarzone, and all content needing to carry over to the battle royale means that every game feels similar. While there are upsides to a seasonal model like free map drops, the idea that multiplayer and Zombies play second fiddle toWarzoneis hard to deny.
Despite offering abattle royalewith Blackout, it certainly did not feel like Treyarch was neglecting the other modes inBlack Ops 4. Multiplayer received plenty of maps and free content, and though the final releases of the Aether storyline were rushed, Zombies offered a stunning launch lineup of four full maps. Blackout being tied to one game meant that all content added toBlack Ops 4could smoothly transition into the battle royale experience, with balancing for all the modes also being an easier task. And though maps were paid, a seasonal format still existed that kept the game fresh long after it launched with some fun themes and new additions.
As the transition period betweenCall of Duty’s loot box eraand a seasonal format,Black Ops 4offered the best of both worlds. AfterBlack Ops 3and the early days ofBlack Ops 4were dubbed pay-to-win games, Treyarch finally found the sweet spot near the end ofBlack Ops 4’s life cycle with Reserves, which let players choose new weapons and skins to unlock just by playing and building up cases. One of the few fair loot box systems, players can hop ontoBlack Ops 4today and obtain the post-launch weapons with relative ease. This came in addition to a completely free Battle Pass, which is essentially unheard of in modern gaming. Without an in-game store full of bundles, all the game’s cosmetic content was earnable, even if it came with a grind attached.
Call of Duty: Black Ops 4 Zombies’ Flaws Do Not Outweigh Its Strengths
WhileCall of Duty: Black Ops 4will not find itself on the top of many fans’ bestCall of Dutygame tier lists, all of its modes were solid and arguably underappreciated. Zombies fits the underappreciated term most of all, as so much of the mode was terrific, and the issues were given far too much attention. Criticisms about the HUD design were valid, but extremely overblown. The performance issues and bugs at launch were obviously an issue, but Treyarch fixed them relatively quickly. The cancelation of Factions was disappointing, but players hardly even knew what the feature would be in the first place. And though the Aether story’s cheaply made final cutscenes and rushed ending will forever be a stain on Zombies, the Chaos story content was absolutely phenomenal.
Apart from its day one problems, much ofCall of Duty: Black Ops 4Zombies’ negative reception comes down to players being unwilling to give the Chaos Story a chance. Truly great maps like Ancient Evil, IX, and Dead of the Night offer stellar Zombies gameplay and tell a story that would have had serious potential if it continued. Unfortunately, it never had a chance since players had decided they were uninterested in the new story before it even began. Further, like the HUD complaints, the hate for the perk system was overblown, as it aimed to fix a longrunning problem. WhileJuggernogand Double Tap may be iconic perks, they are crutches that have to be bought every game, limiting player freedom and gameplay variety. TheBO4perk system addressed this, but instead of assessing it fairly, most could not get over classic perks not being featured. Instead of focusing on fun mechanics like Specialist weapons, improvements like the Max Ammo change and multiplayer pausing, or the dazzling amount of secrets and day one maps, players harped on perks.
Ultimately,Call of Duty: Black Ops 4Zombies is underserving of being labeled a black sheep, as the maps offered in the Chaos story are as deep and unique as they come. Had it not featured lackluster Aether content or suffered from severe crashes that ruined the initial Easter egg hunts - two things that soured many ofCoDZombies’ extremely influential content creators on the game - it would be so much more appreciated. Going back to a map like Ancient Evil to wield the Hammer of Valhalla or the God Hand Wonder Weapons could feel like a wakeup call to players, as they will likely have a lot of fun. Additionally,Black Ops 4Zombies’ four launch maps meant that players had as much round-based content on day one as they had inBlack Ops Cold War’s entire life cycle, which is a truly impressive feat. WithCall of Duty: Modern Warfare 3Zombiestaking a divisive open-world approach, and Easter eggs becoming simpler and less prevalent, the depth and personality ofBlack Ops 4Zombies is sorely missed.
Call of Duty: Black Ops 4’s Blackout and Multiplayer Complimented Each Other Perfectly
While those who dislike long Time-To-Kills inCall of Dutycould be put off byBlack Ops 4, those who do not enjoy fast TTKs of games likeCall of Duty: Modern Warfare2019 will likely adore it. Ultimately, this personal preference will determine how players feel aboutBlack Ops 4multiplayer, as its combat is defined by a long feature due to its healing system, weapon balancing, and more.Black Ops 4’s specialistsworked perfectly with longer TTK, as their weapons and abilities felt less overbearing. It allowed fun new objective modes like Heist and the now-expected experience Control to shine as well. And regardless of whether players enjoy the lengthy gunfights, it is hard to argue that it feels natural to switch between them and Blackout, as players see a consistent TTK across the two experiences.
Though it was a divisive choice, swapping out a campaign for a battle royale mode was ultimately a good call, as Blackout dropped at the height of the battle royale boom. Ultimately, it proved to be a terrific mode, and one that many feel plays better than the free-to-play hitWarzone. While being locked behind a paywall hurt Blackout’s chances to be supported in the long run, there is so much to love about the mode. Character mission unlocks, two great maps (the second of which, Alcatraz, was reskinned asRebirth Island), a fun armor system, interesting abilities, and a colorful map full of locations that celebrateBlack Ops’ history all come together to create a replayable battle royale mode oozing with personality.
Call of Duty: Black Ops4 is the least conventionalCall of Dutygame ever, but it is not close to the worst entry in the franchise.Blackoutis a near-perfect experience, while multiplayer is a solid compromise between what was seen inBlack Ops 3and classicCall of Duty. Zombies is the most head-scratching aspect of all, as players chose to focus on minor flaws like an ugly HUD instead of the entertaining maps full of secrets or the neat story Treyarch was beginning to tell with Chaos. To be clear, this five-year-old game has problems, from lackluster visuals to a nonexistent campaign, and things like the Zombies perk system and multiplayer TTK will forever be controversial. Still, with the biggest issues like bugs and pay-to-win content addressed after launch, it now stands as a good entry in a great franchise. On its anniversary, it deserves to be appreciated for all it did right instead of being bashed for what it did wrong.
Call of Duty: Black Ops 4is available now on PC, PS4, and Xbox One.
MORE:Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 Zombies' Scorcher Looks Like a Cross Between Two Wonder Weapons
